Welcome to Jay's Seafood
Jay's Seafood, located in Dayton, Ohio, is a gem known for its outstanding seafood dishes and classic ambiance. With a diverse menu offering delicious options like the award-winning Clam Chowder, grilled Rare Tuna, and Salmon en Croute, Jay's Seafood is a must-visit for seafood lovers. The upscale yet welcoming atmosphere, along with exceptional service, adds to the overall dining experience. Reviews mention the impressive wine selection, historic building, and impeccable service, making Jay's Seafood a top choice for a memorable dining experience in Dayton. For a delightful and satisfying seafood dining experience, Jay's Seafood is the place to be.
-
225 E 6th St Dayton, OH 45402225 E 6th St Dayton, OH 45402 Hotline: (937) 222-2892
Welcome to Jay's Seafood, a true gem nestled in the heart of Dayton, Ohio, located at 225 E 6th St. This charming seafood restaurant invites you to indulge in a vibrant selection of oceanic delights, offering a menu that caters to seafood aficionados and culinary explorers alike. With its rich history and stunning architecture, the ambiance strikes a perfect balance between cozy and refined, making it ideal for both intimate dinners and lively gatherings.
From the moment you step inside, you're greeted by the warm glow of the mahogany bar and the buzz of camaraderie in the air. The exposed high ceilings and inviting decor echo the vibrant life of The Gem City, making your dining experience all the more memorable. As you settle in, take a moment to explore the impressive wine selection that pairs effortlessly with the restaurant's freshly sourced dishes.
Start your culinary adventure with the Mozzarella Cheese Strips, fried to perfection in a light beer batter and served with honeymustard sauce—the crispy exterior inviting you to bite in, revealing the creamy cheese within. For a taste of the sea, the Clam Chowder is a must-try; this award-winning New England style soup stands out for its rich and hearty flavors. Don't miss the Scallops Andre, featuring large sea scallops enhanced by a luxurious white wine mushroom sauce—an exemplary dish that showcases the kitchen's skill in seafood preparation.
The entrees shine just as brightly, with customer favorites such as the Kobe Burger, which boasts a succulent patty enriched by Vermont cheddar and a crunchy layer of onion straws, all nestled in a brioche roll. It's a land-sea combination that satisfies any burger lover’s craving while ensuring a perfect pairing with one of their crafted cocktails.
Though dining at Jay's is an overall delight, some guests suggest reservations, especially on busy nights. The restaurant can fill quickly, without compromising on earnestly warm service, which remains attentive and jovial throughout your meal. As in every dining journey, it's essential to note potential surprises like added gratuity for larger parties, ensuring clarity for all guests to enjoy their experience fully.
If you're ever in Dayton, allow yourself the opportunity to dine at Jay's Seafood. The beautiful location, divine cuisine, and genuine warmth from the staff create a culinary atmosphere you won't soon forget. So gather your friends, raise a toast at the bar, and dive into flavors that will leave you eagerly planning your next visit.
Great selection of seafood and catches of the day. Prices were moderate and comparable to market price. Nice wine selection and while it's a bit noisy because of 20 ft ceilings the bar and back bar are magnificent
From the mahogany bar to the high ceilings and the history of this place I can't believe this was my first visit. Parking meter inside the front door on those very cold and rainy nights is a plus. We started off with a few drinks and yes they make an old-fashioned but the glass was way too small. So next I went with a Manhattan sans vermouth and it came with a maraschino cherry so I had to 86 that out and ask for Luxardo cherries. Our table ordered a Warped Wing Flyer Red and it came in a can. Nope. Not good. If you're gonna advertise that beer, always make sure it's on draft. The Mozzarella Strips were amazing and it came with honey mustard, but ditch it for other sauces. The Oysters Rockefeller were on point and this party of 6 ordered several. Market Price for Crab Legs is $110/pound. A bit pricey but meaty as all get out. Spiced Bourbon Salmon was flavorful and the Kobe Burger was a hit. We had a party of 6 and although we split it into 3 checks, a 20% gratuity was included on each check with a party of 5 or more which was never discussed until the checks came out. Welp, there goes your tip since it was already included. Very poor management on charging gratuity for 5+ patrons.
Jays is a real gem in The Gem City. The beautiful, historic building. The divine cuisine and the friendly, jovial service make it one of our favorites. We always make sure we get there early to enjoy a well made cocktail at the unique bar.
Food and service were both excellent! I can't wait to return and try other items on the menu. The atmosphere was also very nice and relaxing.
I would encourage to have a reservation. The place was packed on a Friday evening. The service was very good. The best scallops I had in Dayton. The shrimp was also very good, flavorful and soft. I got the gumbo (chefs special - not on the menu). It was good. The sausage had a unique flavor. Wife got the pasta which was decent as well. The place looks a little old. They validate the parking.
We recall dining at Yankee Tavern in Centerville; Kudos to Amy. We have recommended Jay's Seafood Restaurant since 1976, and in our view and many others Jay's Seafood Restaurant is the best seafood restaurant in Dayton. While Jay's Seafood Restaurant merits five star meals, it is upscale casual; but not too casual. Restaurant is old school architecture, and the bar is a centerpiece. Caveat: Reservations are necessary, and we prefer earlier rather than later. Jay's is in Oregon District and offers a parking lot. Fresh fish is the reason to dine; although there are other food items. Years ago we learned the delights of Jay's Seafood Restaurant, and Jay's Seafood Restaurant does a great business. We nearly always order the menu's fresh fish; my wife is partial to Linguine al Frutti di Mal. Dining Five Star Service Five Star Ambience Five Star The tariff is appropriate for the fare.
We've been back to Jay's twice, service has been great both times. Our waiter on the last visit was Tucker and tonight Bronson. Very knowledgeable regarding the menu and great recommendations. He brought a very positive vibe to the experience. The Artichokes app and both our seafood entrees were excellent. So flavorful. Even the salads were worthy of note. The ingredients are high quality all around and the presentation is mouth-watering! Fresh seafood has to travel far to get here, and price reflects that expense. And it's well worth the cost. Highly recommended. I'm coming back for lobster!
My first time dining here was actually on my birthday. My husband and I decided to celebrate at this location and we had a wonderful time. My very favorite detail about Jay's seafood is how unfussy the vibe is. You get excellent quality food, great service, but nothing feels pretentious. Our waitress chatted with us, and we felt right at home while eating some truly delicious seafood. I am a big raw oyster fan, and their oysters were so fresh and so delicious that I would come back just to have a glass of wine and a dozen oysters. I also enjoyed the muscles as my entree, and they were delicious. This is a great gem in downtown Dayton, and a great spot if you're a big seafood lover like me.